Harriette Simpson Arnow: “The Dollmaker”

See image credit below.

See image credit below.

Chances are you may have seen the Jane Fonda made-for-TV adaptation of Harriette Simpson Arnow’s 1954 novel, The Dollmaker. It’s a decent adaptation, as far as made-for-TV movies go. But if you haven’t read the novel itself, you’re missing out on an often-overlooked masterpiece of American literature.

Arnow brings to vivid life what singer-songwriter Steve Earle dubbed the “Hillbilly Highway,”iconwhat scholars call “Appalachian out-migration” or the “Appalachian diaspora.” (See, for example, my friend Chad Berry’s first book, Southern Migrants, Northern Exiles.)

Simply put, many southern Appalachians found they could not survive economically by staying in the mountains, and many of them moved to northern industrialized cities to look for factory work. Cincinnati, Baltimore, Detroit, and other cities became prime destinations for these mountaineers, especially during World War II, when they could get jobs in the defense industry. (You may also recall an earlier StoryWeb post on bluegrass singer-songwriter Hazel Dickens and her song “Mama’s Hand,” which tells of leaving home in West Virginia to seek work in Baltimore.)

Arnow’s heroine, Gertie Nevels, hails from the hills of eastern Kentucky. The novel opens with a scene in which Gertie, desperate to get her sick child to a doctor, flags down a car on the road near her house. From this gripping opener all the way through to the end of this long, rich novel, Gertie faces one heart-wrenching ordeal after another.

Not long after the child survives, Gertie and her husband make the difficult decision to leave their Kentucky home to move to Detroit, where relatives and friends have found work in the factories. They set up housekeeping in a company house – though “house” is too lofty a word for the structure they find themselves living in. A row house of sorts, the thin walls barely give them any privacy from their neighbors, and the “home” is situated in an industrialized setting. Cut off from the natural world they had loved so well in Kentucky, they and their five children are forced to pursue their lives in a barren, mechanized world. It will lead to heartbreak for all of them, especially Gertie.

I don’t want to give away the story, but I can share a few teasers. Gertie is a dollmaker, excelling at the traditional craft of the mountains. Given her artistic sensibilities, it comes as no surprise when she goes one step further and begins to carve a beautiful block of wood. You’ll have to read the novel to find out what Gertie discovers in that block of wood.

The Dollmaker is a gripping, if emotionally difficult, novel to read. Arnow pulls no punches in her depiction of the Nevels’s life in Detroit, and her commentary about Appalachian out-migration is sad indeed. But the book is so well written and so compelling that it’s worth the tears you’ll shed reading it.

Don’t forget to leave a comment on this post! You’ll be entered into a monthly drawing to win a StoryWeb T-shirt if you do one of the following. 1) Subscribe to the weekly StoryWeb email, and leave a comment here (or on any other post!). 2) Subscribe to the StoryWeb podcast in iTunes, and leave a review on iTunes. (If you subscribe on iTunes and leave a review there, shoot me an email at linda@thestoryweb.com to let me know you did so!)

Watch:Watch this five-minute clip from the opening of the TV adaptation of The Dollmaker, starring Jane Fonda as Gertie Nevels. (And if you want to read the opening chapter on which this scene is based, visit this page and click on “Read an Excerpt.”) You might also want to watch a young Steve Earle sing “Hillbilly Highway” on “Austin City Limits.”

Image credit: Harriette Simpson Arnow, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Harriette_Simpson_Arnow.jpg

Comments

  1. This prompts me to pull Dollmaker off my shelf for another read. The first was a very long time ago. Thank you, Linda. I also took a nice stroll down a YouTube path and revisited a lot of good music!

  2. Can’t wait to share this and the other riches of StoryWeb with the teachers at The Lab School of Washington! Thanks for this amazing resource!

  3. This is one of my favorite books, thanks for bringing it to mind again. I’m going to read it again. So many good books–thanks for reminding us of the treasures. Bonnie

  4. love..one of my favorite

  5. Uncle Henry Tate says

    I really liked the Introduction, but it had more descriptive prose than I am usually ready to read. Good story (I’ll wait for the movie) perhaps Pam will read it and give me the edited version. H

Speak Your Mind

Your email address will not be published on the site.

*